If your baby’s arm was injured during a hard St. Louis delivery, you may have an Erb’s palsy claim. That depends on whether the delivery care fell below accepted practice and caused the nerve damage.
What to do now:
Chris Dixon grew up in St. Louis. He helps families find out whether a birth injury could have been prevented and who should answer for it. He has recovered more than $60 million for the people he represents, and there’s no fee unless we win.
Call 314-208-2808 any time, day or night, to talk through what happened.
Key Takeaways
On This Page:
An Erb’s palsy case decides who pays for therapy, any nerve or shoulder surgery, and the work your child may not be able to do as an adult. In Missouri, a child injured at birth generally has until the 20th birthday to file a malpractice claim under Mo. Rev. Stat. § 516.105.1, even though adults face a 10-year outer limit. That sounds like plenty of time.
It often isn’t.
A statute of repose is an outer time limit that can bar a claim no matter when the harm was discovered. For adults, Missouri’s repose period is 10 years from the act of neglect. The Missouri Supreme Court has held that it can’t be equitably tolled (Ambers-Phillips v. SSM DePaul Health Ctr., 459 S.W.3d 901 (Mo. banc 2015)). For a minor, the statute uses the later of 10 years or two years after the 18th birthday. That’s why a child injured at birth generally has until age 20.
A single delivery can create more than one claim. The mother’s own injuries are an adult claim with a 2-year limit that starts at the act of neglect. Missouri starts that clock at discovery only in two situations: a foreign object left in the body, or a failure to report test results. The parents’ claim for the child’s medical bills before adulthood may also be separate. We confirm that deadline for each family. We never assume it matches the child’s.
Evidence also has a shelf life. Nurses change jobs, and memories of a few tense minutes in the delivery room fade. Under Brown v. Hamid, 856 S.W.2d 51 (Mo. banc 1993), a Missouri jury may infer that missing evidence was harmful only if it was destroyed or altered in bad faith. That’s why an early written request to preserve the chart carries more weight than a later complaint about missing records.
Some St. Louis families get prenatal care at federally funded community health centers. If the provider is treated as a federal employee, the claim may fall under the Federal Tort Claims Act. That law requires a written administrative claim to the agency within 2 years (28 U.S.C. § 2401(b)) before any lawsuit can be filed (28 U.S.C. § 2675(a)). Federal timing rules then apply instead of Missouri’s.
| Claim | Filing deadline | Source | Key exception or limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Child’s own malpractice claim (injured before age 18) | Until the 20th birthday | Mo. Rev. Stat. § 516.105.1(3) | Outer limit is the later of 10 years from the act or 2 years after the 18th birthday |
| Mother’s own injury claim (adult) | 2 years from the act of neglect | Mo. Rev. Stat. § 516.105.1 | Discovery starts the clock only for a retained foreign object or unreported test results |
| Parents’ claim for the child’s medical expenses | Must be confirmed for your case | Researched case by case | May not match the child’s age-20 deadline, so it should be checked first |
| Claim involving a federally deemed clinic or federal facility | Written agency claim within 2 years | 28 U.S.C. § 2401(b); 28 U.S.C. § 2675(a) | No lawsuit until the agency claim is filed and resolved |
Erb’s palsy is weakness or paralysis in a baby’s shoulder and arm. It happens when the upper nerves of the brachial plexus are damaged, most often during delivery. When a baby’s head and neck are pulled away from the shoulder during birth, those nerves can stretch or tear.
The brachial plexus is the bundle of nerves that runs from the spinal cord in the neck down into the shoulder, arm and hand. Erb’s palsy involves the upper part, usually the C5 and C6 nerve roots. Klumpke’s palsy involves the lower roots and mainly affects the hand and wrist. Some babies have damage to the whole plexus.
The arm may hang limp at the baby’s side, turned inward, with the wrist bent. Doctors sometimes call this the “waiter’s tip” position. Your baby may not move that arm when startled. Grip may be weak, or the arm may move only partway.
Brachial plexus injuries range in severity:
Treatment usually starts with physical and occupational therapy. Some children are referred to specialists who may consider nerve grafts or nerve transfers, and later shoulder or tendon procedures. Some babies regain much or all movement in the first months. Others keep lasting weakness. Only your child’s doctors can speak to your child’s outlook.
Key insight: Waiting to see how the arm recovers makes sense medically. But it doesn’t pause the mother’s 2-year clock or protect records from loss.
In Missouri, Erb’s palsy is malpractice only when a provider failed to meet the standard of care and that failure caused the nerve injury. A brachial plexus injury can happen even when a delivery is handled correctly, so the injury alone never proves negligence.
The standard of care is what a reasonably careful provider in the same field would have done in similar circumstances. Proving a departure from it almost always takes testimony from qualified medical experts. As a trial lawyer who prepares every case as though a jury will hear it, Chris Dixon starts from the records and the medical review, not from assumptions about what went wrong.
Shoulder dystocia is a delivery emergency. The baby’s head is born, but a shoulder gets caught behind the mother’s pubic bone. Obstetric teams train for it with recognized maneuvers. Examples include the McRoberts maneuver (pulling the mother’s legs back toward her chest), pressure just above the pubic bone, delivering the back arm, and rotating the baby’s shoulders.
Many shoulder dystocia lawsuits turn on how hard and in which direction the head was pulled. Excessive sideways traction on the head is a common focus. Experts also look at whether pressure was pushed down on the top of the uterus. Obstetric guidance generally warns against that during shoulder dystocia. Was help called? Were the maneuvers performed and recorded in order?
Some cases begin weeks earlier. Reviewers look at whether the team noticed and responded to known risk factors:
The question isn’t whether those risks existed. It’s whether the team recognized them and discussed the delivery options, including a cesarean, in a way that matched accepted practice.
Defense experts may say the natural forces of labor caused the injury, not the provider’s hands. That’s a real medical debate, and it’s why independent review matters. Parents often focus on the baby’s size. But many of these cases hinge on something quieter: when the delivery note was written. A note written after the team noticed the limp arm can read differently than one written at the time. The chart’s electronic audit trail can show which one you have.
Erb’s palsy is a nerve injury in the arm. Cerebral palsy is a brain injury. Both are birth injuries, but the medical proof and the experts involved differ. For a wider look at how Missouri malpractice claims work, see our St. Louis medical malpractice lawyer page.
In Missouri, responsibility for a birth-related brachial plexus injury can rest with any provider whose care fell below the standard and caused the harm. It can also fall on a facility that answers for that provider. Who made the decision at issue shapes who is named in the lawsuit and what must be proven.
People and organizations that may be involved include:
Claims of hospital negligence often raise questions about the unit itself. Was an experienced provider available? Did the hospital have a shoulder dystocia protocol, and did staff follow it?
Not every provider in the room works for the hospital. Some physicians are independent contractors, and that affects who may be held responsible for them. And as noted above, a federally deemed clinic changes the procedure entirely. We sort this out from employment records and the chart before deciding who belongs in the case.
We evaluate birth injury claims using what we call the Chart-to-Consequence Framework. Each step answers one question, and each answer shapes the next decision. Timing comes first, because a missed deadline ends a claim no matter how strong the medical proof is.
This framework is a way of organizing the work, not a promise about where it leads. Every case depends on its own records and medical opinions.
If you’re holding a discharge summary and a referral to a specialist, that’s a fine place to start. Call 314-208-2808 and bring whatever paperwork you have.
In a Missouri shoulder dystocia lawsuit, the most important evidence is usually the complete labor and delivery chart, not the summary. Patients have a federal right to copies of their medical records under 45 C.F.R. § 164.524, and parents can generally request their baby’s records as the child’s representative.
Ask for the complete chart in writing. “Records from the delivery” sometimes produces only a few pages.
| Record | What it can show | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Prenatal records and ultrasounds | Estimated fetal weight, glucose screening, prior delivery history | Shows which risk factors were known before labor |
| Fetal heart-rate monitoring strips | The baby’s condition and the pattern of contractions through labor | Helps rebuild the timeline of labor and delivery |
| Delivery note and shoulder dystocia documentation | Maneuvers used, their order, and the time between head and body delivery | Shows how the emergency was handled |
| Labor and delivery nursing notes | Who was present, when help was called, and what nurses observed | Can confirm or contradict the physician’s account |
| Electronic audit trail | When entries were made, changed or added | Can reveal late or altered documentation |
| Newborn, NICU and specialist records | Arm exam at birth, EMG or MRI results, therapy progress | Documents the injury’s severity and course |
Keep your own records too. Therapy appointment cards, photos and videos of your child’s arm, and a simple journal can all help show how the injury has changed daily life.
A Missouri Erb’s palsy claim can seek economic losses, such as medical and future care costs, and noneconomic losses, such as pain and lost enjoyment of life. Mo. Rev. Stat. § 538.210 limits noneconomic damages in medical malpractice cases, but that limit doesn’t apply to medical bills, care costs or lost earning capacity.
A life care plan is a detailed projection, usually prepared by a specialist, of the medical care, therapy, equipment and support a child will need over a lifetime. It’s often the backbone of the damages case when an injury is permanent. Families with lifelong needs may also find our catastrophic injury page useful.
| Damage category | Examples in an Erb’s palsy case | Subject to the § 538.210 limit? | How it’s usually proven |
|---|---|---|---|
| Past medical expenses | NICU care, specialist visits, imaging, therapy to date | No | Bills and medical records |
| Future medical and care costs | Ongoing therapy, nerve or shoulder surgery, braces and equipment | No | Life care plan and treating-physician opinions |
| Lost earning capacity | Reduced ability to do certain jobs as an adult | No | Vocational and economic analysis |
| Noneconomic damages | Pain, physical limits, lost enjoyment of life, disfigurement | Yes | Testimony from family, doctors and therapists |
Missouri doesn’t allow personal injury claims to be assigned. As a result, ordinary privately insured health plans generally can’t enforce repayment against a Missouri injury recovery (Waye v. Bankers Multiple Line Ins. Co., 796 S.W.2d 660 (Mo. App. W.D. 1990)). MO HealthNet can recover under Mo. Rev. Stat. § 208.215. So can Medicare and federally governed plans, such as self-funded employer ERISA plans and federal-employee FEHBA plans. Many newborns are covered by MO HealthNet, so this question comes up often.
Settlements for a minor usually need court approval. They’re often structured over time or placed in a special needs trust to protect eligibility for public benefits. Planning for that early keeps the money working for your child. For a broader look at value, see what affects an injury case’s worth.
In a malpractice case, venue under Mo. Rev. Stat. § 508.010 is set by Mo. Rev. Stat. § 538.232: the patient is treated as injured only in the county where they first received treatment from a defendant for the condition at issue. For a birth injury, that can be the county of the prenatal office rather than the delivery hospital, so the right court depends on where a defendant’s care began.
The City of St. Louis and St. Louis County are separate jurisdictions. Each has its own circuit court:
Those hospital names are only location examples. They say nothing about care at any facility. Once a case is filed, the court and division assigned to it appear on the case filings. You can look up Missouri state court cases through Missouri Courts and its Case.net system.
Some St. Louis families deliver at Metro East hospitals across the Mississippi. An Illinois delivery doesn’t automatically move the case to Illinois: where it can be filed and which state’s law applies depend on who the defendants are, where their care began and which state has the most significant relationship to the claim. Chris Dixon is licensed in both Missouri and Illinois, so we can review where the claim belongs before any deadline is assumed.
We don’t give average timelines, because they depend on facts that vary widely. These factors matter most:
When you call The Dixon Injury Firm, you’re talking with a firm that accepts cases selectively and gives each family personal attention. Every client works directly with the attorney handling the case, not a case manager or call center.
Here’s what we can commit to:
Christopher R. Dixon is the founder and managing attorney of The Dixon Injury Firm. He was born and raised in St. Louis and has practiced since 2007. During law school, he gained courtroom experience working with the St. Louis City Circuit Attorney’s Office. He’s admitted to The Missouri Bar and the Illinois Bar. He earned his J.D. from Oklahoma City University School of Law and his B.S. from the University of Missouri–Columbia.
His recognitions include The Best Lawyers in America® 2027 — Personal Injury Litigation – Plaintiffs, Super Lawyers®, Top 100 Trial Lawyers, The National Trial Lawyers, and Lifetime Membership, Million Dollar Advocates Forum. Chris also co-founded The St. Louis Suit Project, a 501(c)(3) charitable organization. Awards and past results reflect past work. They can’t predict what will happen in your child’s case.
The information on this page is for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Every case is unique, and past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Contact a qualified attorney to discuss your specific situation.
You don’t need to know yet whether the delivery was handled correctly. That’s what the records and the medical review are for. What you do need to know is that the mother’s own claim generally has a 2-year limit from the delivery, and a parent’s claim for the child’s medical bills may not share the child’s deadline.
Bring the discharge papers, any specialist notes and your questions. Chris Dixon and our team serve families in St. Louis, Clayton, Florissant and St. Charles County, and you can learn more about our broader medical malpractice practice. Call 314-208-2808 to start the conversation.
You may. In Missouri, a claim exists only if qualified medical review shows the delivery team’s care fell below the standard of care and that failure caused your baby’s nerve injury. Erb’s palsy alone doesn’t prove malpractice, because brachial plexus injuries can happen even with appropriate care. The answer usually comes from the complete labor and delivery chart, not the discharge papers.
Under Mo. Rev. Stat. § 516.105.1, a child injured at birth generally has until the 20th birthday to file. The mother’s own injury claim is an adult claim with a 2-year limit from the act of neglect. The parents’ claim for the child’s medical expenses may follow a different deadline, so confirm it early. If a federally deemed clinic was involved, a written administrative claim is required within two years under 28 U.S.C. § 2401(b).
The Dixon Injury Firm handles these cases with no fee unless we win, so you don’t pay attorney fees up front. Malpractice cases also involve expenses, such as expert reviews and records, that are separate from attorney fees. Ask us how those expenses are handled in your case, and we’ll walk through it with you before you decide anything.
There’s no reliable way to value a case before the records are reviewed and your child’s long-term outlook is clearer. Value depends on whether the injury is permanent, what surgeries and therapy are needed, the future care in a life care plan, and how strong the proof of fault and causation is. Missouri also limits noneconomic damages in malpractice cases under Mo. Rev. Stat. § 538.210. That limit doesn’t apply to medical and care costs.
Not before you understand your child’s likely future care needs and any repayment obligations. In birth injury cases, an offer usually comes from a hospital’s or physician’s liability insurer or a self-insured health system. You’ll also need to know whether MO HealthNet or a federally governed plan must be repaid. A minor’s settlement generally needs court approval too. Here’s more on evaluating a first insurance offer.
Many parents blame themselves, but these cases are about the medical care, not about you. Missouri generally follows pure comparative fault under Gustafson v. Benda, 661 S.W.2d 11 (Mo. banc 1983). However, the rule for allocating fault in a health-care claim must be confirmed in each case. A newborn’s own conduct isn’t at issue in the child’s claim.
In Missouri, the timeline depends on the facts rather than a set schedule. The biggest factors are how quickly your child’s long-term outlook becomes clear, how long expert review takes, and how many providers are involved. The court’s schedule and whether the parties mediate also matter. Some families wait to see how much the arm recovers before valuing the claim, but the mother’s 2-year deadline keeps running.
Missouri law doesn’t require one. But malpractice claims almost always require expert testimony on the standard of care, breach and causation. They also involve detailed records, liens from MO HealthNet or federally governed plans, and court approval for a child’s settlement. Hospitals and physicians typically have defense counsel from the start.
Hospitals and physician groups commonly carry professional liability coverage or self-insure. Limits and who is covered vary, so identifying coverage is part of the early investigation. If the provider was a federally deemed clinic, the Federal Tort Claims Act applies and the claim proceeds against the United States after a written agency claim.
Many medical malpractice cases resolve through settlement, but some go to trial. Whether yours does depends on the strength of the medical proof, the defense’s evaluation and what serves your family. We prepare each case as though a jury will hear it, which keeps trial available if a fair resolution isn’t offered. No one can promise which path a case will take.
Most families rely on health insurance or MO HealthNet while a claim is pending. Missouri’s First Steps early intervention program is worth asking your pediatrician about. In Missouri, ordinary private health plans generally can’t take repayment from an injury recovery. MO HealthNet, Medicare and federally governed plans can, so those amounts are addressed before any settlement is finalized.
Improvement is good news, and it can affect the value of a claim. Some lasting effects, like reduced shoulder movement or strength, only become clear as a child grows. Specialist records over time help show the injury’s true course. Recovery doesn’t pause any deadline, especially the mother’s 2-year limit.
Often, yes. Signing a general consent form for labor and delivery doesn’t, by itself, permit care that falls below accepted practice. In some cases, the question is whether risks and options, such as a cesarean, were actually discussed. A review of the prenatal and delivery records shows what was documented.
Many personal injury law factories get as many clients in the door as possible, hoping one will be the jackpot. Not us. At The Dixon Injury Firm, we’re highly selective about our cases because we devote considerable time and attention to each client.