Home \ St. Louis Car Accident Lawyer \ St. Louis Underinsured Motorist Claims Lawyer

St. Louis Underinsured Motorist Claims Lawyer

If the driver who hit you in St. Louis carried too little insurance, your own underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage may cover part of the gap. That depends on two things: whether you bought UIM, and whether your policy’s definition of “underinsured” fits your crash.

What to do now:

  1. Pull your declarations page. It shows whether you carry UIM and the limit on each vehicle.
  2. Notify your own insurer in writing. Your policy’s notice and cooperation conditions apply to this claim.
  3. Hold off on signing any release. Some policies set conditions on settling with the other driver. An injury suit against that driver generally must be filed within 5 years.

Chris Dixon was born and raised in St. Louis. He takes on insurance companies, including a client’s own carrier, when a crash causes more harm than the at-fault driver’s policy can pay. Over his career, he has recovered more than $60 million for injured people and grieving families. You pay no fee unless we win.

Call 314-208-2808 to talk through your policy with our team.

Key Takeaways

  • Missouri does not require underinsured motorist coverage, so your policy’s definition decides when it pays. Under wording that compares liability limits, UIM pays nothing when the other driver’s limits equal or exceed your UIM limits (Rodriguez v. General Accident Ins. Co. of Am., 808 S.W.2d 379 (Mo. banc 1991)).
  • Every Missouri personal auto liability policy must include uninsured motorist (UM) coverage of at least $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident (Mo. Rev. Stat. § 379.203.1). UIM is a separate, optional coverage.
  • A policy term that shortens your time to sue your own insurer is void under Mo. Rev. Stat. § 431.030. The policy’s prompt-notice and cooperation conditions still apply.
  • A Missouri personal injury suit against the at-fault driver generally must be filed within 5 years (§ 516.120). A wrongful death suit must be filed within 3 years of the death (§ 537.100).
  • Missouri uses pure comparative fault (Gustafson v. Benda, 661 S.W.2d 11 (Mo. banc 1983)). Your share of fault reduces your recovery but does not bar it, even above 50%.

On This Page:

Why St. Louis Drivers Bring UIM Disputes to Chris Dixon

A UIM claim is an odd fight. The company resisting payment is the one you’ve paid premiums to for years. On a UIM claim, your own insurer can question your injuries, your treatment, and your share of fault, the same way the other driver’s carrier would.

Chris Dixon prepares cases with trial in mind. His early courtroom experience came from working with the St. Louis City Circuit Attorney’s Office during law school. Today he is listed in The Best Lawyers in America® 2027 for Personal Injury Litigation – Plaintiffs. He has also been selected by Super Lawyers® and named to the Top 100 Trial Lawyers by The National Trial Lawyers. Clients have given the firm a 5-star Google rating across 406 reviews.

You can read more about his background on Chris Dixon’s attorney profile.

Results in claims where coverage was limited

These documented results involved coverage limits or a claim against the client’s own carrier:

  • $1 million settlement: The at-fault driver had no insurance at all. We fought our client’s own uninsured motorist carrier to obtain his $1,000,000 policy limits.
  • $500,000 settlement: We recovered the full policy limits for both a driver and a passenger, $250,000 each, even though the injuries were relatively minor back injuries.
  • Confidential settlement: Our client was riding with an intoxicated driver who drove off the road and into a tree. The client’s injuries were life-altering, and the applicable insurance policies could not cover them.

Past results reflect the facts of those cases. They don’t predict what will happen in yours.

A team that knows how carriers evaluate claims

Michael Langella brings a background defending insurance companies to his work for injured clients. That perspective matters when your own insurer starts building its case against your claim. And every client works directly with the attorney handling the case, not a call center.

If you’re still sorting out the crash itself, our St. Louis car accident lawyer page covers the broader claim.

What Does a St. Louis Underinsured Motorist Attorney Cost?

You pay nothing unless we recover for you. The Dixon Injury Firm handles car accident claims, including UIM claims against your own insurer, on a contingency basis, so there’s no upfront attorney fee.

Contingency fee means the attorney’s fee comes from the money recovered, as a percentage set in the written agreement. If there’s no recovery, there’s no attorney fee.

Case expenses are a separate question. Records, filing fees, and expert costs can come up in some claims. Ask us how expenses are handled, and read the fee agreement before you sign. It spells out both the fee and the expenses.

Most people worry about one more thing. Will hiring a lawyer against my own insurer cause trouble? Your policy is a contract. Asking someone to enforce it is a normal part of how coverage disputes get resolved.

The firm is available 24/7. That helps when a crash happens on a Friday night on I-270 and you have questions before the adjuster calls Monday.

What Is Underinsured Motorist Coverage in Missouri?

Underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage is optional insurance you buy on your own auto policy. It can pay part of your losses when the at-fault driver has some liability insurance, but not enough under your policy’s terms. Missouri does not require UIM coverage, so whether it applies, and how much it pays, depends on your policy’s own language.

That’s different from uninsured motorist coverage. Missouri requires UM in every personal auto liability policy at the minimum limits in Mo. Rev. Stat. § 379.203.1. That covers $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident.

The minimum liability limits for Missouri drivers are 25/50/25: $25,000 per injured person, $50,000 per accident, and $25,000 for property damage (§ 303.190). A driver who carries only the minimum has $25,000 available for your injuries. A serious injury involving surgery or months off work can exceed that.

Uninsured drivers are common too. More than 1 in 7 drivers (15.4%) on U.S. roads was uninsured in 2023, according to the Insurance Research Council (2025).

Where to find your coverage

Your declarations page is the summary sheet at the front of your auto policy. It lists each covered vehicle, each coverage you bought, and the dollar limit for each. If “underinsured motorist” doesn’t appear there, you likely didn’t purchase it. Check every policy in your household before you assume that, though.

FeatureUninsured Motorist (UM)Underinsured Motorist (UIM)
Required in Missouri?Yes, at least $25,000 per person / $50,000 per accident (§ 379.203.1)No, optional coverage
When it appliesAt-fault driver has no insurance, or a hit-and-run driver left before being identifiedAt-fault driver has insurance but meets your policy’s definition of “underinsured”
Who you claim againstYour own insurerYour own insurer
What controls coverageThe statute is part of the policy; exclusions and set-offs can be enforced above the minimumThe policy’s definitions, limits, and reduction terms
Hit-and-run crashesCovered whether or not the vehicles made physical contact (§ 379.203.1); policy notice and reporting conditions still applyNot the usual route; an unidentified driver is handled under UM coverage

When Does Missouri Law Treat a Driver as Underinsured?

Most people assume UIM kicks in whenever their losses are bigger than the other driver’s policy. That’s not how many Missouri policies work. Many Missouri policies define an underinsured driver by comparing the other driver’s liability limits to your UIM limits, not to your losses. Under that wording, UIM pays nothing when the other driver’s limits equal or exceed your UIM limits (Rodriguez v. General Accident Ins. Co. of Am., 808 S.W.2d 379 (Mo. banc 1991)).

So a person with $25,000 in UIM coverage who’s hit by a driver carrying $25,000 in liability may get nothing from UIM, even with $150,000 in medical bills. It feels backward. But it’s what the contract says, and Missouri’s highest court has enforced that kind of definition.

Not every policy uses the same wording. That’s why we read the whole policy, including endorsements, before anyone tells you what UIM will or won’t pay.

An illustrative comparison

The scenarios below are hypothetical. They show how a limits-comparison definition plays out. Your policy may be worded differently.

ScenarioAt-fault driver’s bodily injury limitYour UIM limitResult under limits-comparison wording
A$25,000$25,000Not underinsured; UIM pays nothing
B$50,000$25,000Not underinsured; UIM pays nothing
C$100,000$100,000Not underinsured; UIM pays nothing
D$25,000$100,000May qualify as underinsured; payment depends on the policy’s reduction terms

Why scenario D still needs a close read

A set-off, sometimes called a reduction clause, is a policy term that subtracts money you received from another source, such as the at-fault driver’s insurer, from what UIM will pay. In scenario D, a set-off might reduce your $100,000 UIM limit by the $25,000 you got from the other driver. Whether it does depends entirely on the wording.

Here’s what that means for you. Two people with the same injuries and the same UIM limit can get very different answers, purely because of policy language. Our guide on what a car accident case is worth in Missouri explains how damages are valued. Coverage terms decide how much of that value can actually be collected.

Can You Stack Underinsured Motorist Coverage in Missouri?

Stacking means combining the UIM limits from more than one vehicle or more than one policy to create a larger pool of coverage. For example, a household with three insured cars and $50,000 in UIM on each might argue for $150,000 instead of $50,000.

Because UIM is optional in Missouri, the policy’s terms, including any anti-stacking clause, generally decide whether UIM limits can be combined. An anti-stacking clause is policy language that tries to limit you to one vehicle’s coverage no matter how many vehicles you insure.

But there’s a catch. Policies don’t always say the same thing in every section. The declarations page, the UIM endorsement, and the “other insurance” provisions each need to be read together.

Questions we check on stacking

  1. How many vehicles are listed on your policy, and does each carry UIM?
  2. Does anyone else in your household have a separate auto policy?
  3. Could you qualify as a covered person under a household member’s policy?
  4. What does the anti-stacking or “other insurance” language actually say?
  5. Did you pay a separate UIM premium for each vehicle?

Bring every declarations page in your household to your first conversation with us. Stacking questions can’t be answered from memory.

How Does a UIM Claim Work When Your Own Insurer Pays?

A UIM claim usually runs in two tracks. First comes the claim against the at-fault driver and that driver’s insurer. Then comes the claim against your own insurer for the gap your policy covers. In Missouri, your own policy’s notice and cooperation conditions apply to a UIM claim, so your insurer should hear about the crash and any settlement offer from the other driver early.

The usual order of a UIM claim

  1. Report the crash and get treatment. Medical records from the start tie your injuries to the collision.
  2. Notify your own insurer in writing. Do this even if you expect the other driver’s carrier to pay.
  3. Confirm the at-fault driver’s limits. You need that number to apply your policy’s definition of “underinsured.”
  4. Check your policy before accepting the other driver’s limits. Some policies set conditions on settling with or releasing the at-fault driver.
  5. Document your full losses. That means medical bills, future care, lost wages, and how the injury changed your daily life.
  6. Submit a UIM demand to your insurer. It should lay out liability, damages, and how your policy applies.
  7. Negotiate or file suit. If your insurer won’t pay what the policy and evidence support, a lawsuit may follow.

Our overview of the personal injury claim process walks through settlement stages in more detail.

When your own insurer becomes the opposing side

UIM payment usually depends on what you could have recovered from the at-fault driver. That means fault and damages still matter. Your insurer can argue that you share the blame or that your injuries came from something else.

Pure comparative fault means your recovery is reduced by your own percentage of fault, but you can still recover even if you were more than 50% at fault. Missouri adopted this rule in Gustafson v. Benda, 661 S.W.2d 11 (Mo. banc 1983). At trial, the jury finds total damages and each party’s percentage. The court then reduces the award by your share.

Greg Motil‘s defense-side experience helps anticipate the fault-shifting arguments carriers raise. Common ones include treatment gaps, prior injuries, and low property damage. Our page on insurance company tactics that devalue claims covers more of them.

One more difference: you generally don’t have to give the other driver’s insurer a recorded statement. Your own policy’s cooperation conditions, though, can require you to provide information to your carrier. Read those terms, or have us read them, before you respond.

Applying the Dixon Impact-to-Recovery Framework to a UIM Claim

The Dixon Impact-to-Recovery Framework is our six-step approach to Missouri car accident claims. On a UIM claim, the coverage and settlement steps carry the most weight. Each claim still turns on its own facts and policy terms, and this approach doesn’t predict any outcome.

  1. Lock Down What Happened. We gather the police report, scene photos, and nearby video before footage is overwritten. Our knowledge of St. Louis traffic patterns helps us find where cameras or witnesses may be.
  2. Identify Every Responsible Party. Missouri requires every driver to use “the highest degree of care” (RSMo § 304.012). An employer, a rideshare company, or a second driver may add another source of coverage beyond the one underinsured driver.
  3. Connect Each Injury to the Crash. Your own insurer can dispute causation as hard as any other carrier. We use emergency records, imaging, and prior history to answer that.
  4. Measure Today’s and Tomorrow’s Losses. Counting future care and lost earning capacity shows how far your losses exceed the at-fault driver’s limits. Whether UIM pays that difference depends on your policy’s definition of an underinsured motor vehicle. If you’re still treating, valuation may wait, balanced against the filing deadline.
  5. Find Every Source of Coverage. This step drives UIM claims. We review the at-fault driver’s policy, any employer or umbrella policy, and every household declarations page for UIM and stacking terms.
  6. Choose Between Negotiating and Filing Suit. If your insurer’s offer reflects the evidence and the policy, settlement may make sense. If it doesn’t, or a deadline is near, we may file suit.

Expert help, such as crash reconstruction or medical opinions, is decided case by case. It isn’t a routine step in every claim.

Have the other driver’s limits already been offered to you? Call 314-208-2808 before you sign anything. We’ll walk through your policy’s settlement conditions and what your UIM coverage may add.

How Long Do You Have to Bring a UIM Claim in Missouri?

In Missouri, an injury suit against the at-fault driver generally must be filed within 5 years under RSMo § 516.120. Your policy cannot shorten the time to sue your own insurer, because Mo. Rev. Stat. § 431.030 voids contract terms that shorten the time to sue. Prompt notice still matters. Your policy’s notice and cooperation conditions apply even though they aren’t the deadline to sue.

Exactly when the clock starts on a UIM claim against your insurer can depend on the facts. That’s why we confirm every applicable deadline at the start.

ClaimAgainst whomTime ruleSource
Personal injury lawsuitAt-fault driverGenerally 5 yearsMo. Rev. Stat. § 516.120
Wrongful death lawsuitAt-fault driver3 years from the deathMo. Rev. Stat. § 537.100
Property damage lawsuitAt-fault driverGenerally 5 yearsMo. Rev. Stat. § 516.120
UIM or UM claimYour own insurerSet by Missouri law; policy terms shortening the time to sue are voidMo. Rev. Stat. § 431.030
Notice to your insurerYour own insurerPrompt notice and cooperation, as the policy requiresYour policy’s conditions

When a crash takes a life

Missouri wrongful death claims must be filed within 3 years of the death (§ 537.100). Under RSMo § 537.080, the first right to bring the claim belongs to the spouse, children, descendants of deceased children, or parents. Siblings or their descendants may file only when no one in that first group survives. A court-appointed plaintiff ad litem may file only when neither group survives. Our St. Louis wrongful death lawyer page covers these claims in depth.

Filing in St. Louis City, St. Louis County, or St. Charles County

Venue is the legal term for the county where a lawsuit must be filed. When you were first injured in Missouri, Mo. Rev. Stat. § 508.010.4 requires a tort suit to be filed in the county where you were first injured, regardless of where the defendants live or do business. A suit against your own insurer over UIM is a contract claim, and its venue is confirmed separately.

That makes the exact crash location matter. Highways like I-64, I-44, I-55, and I-70 cross between the City of St. Louis and St. Louis County. A few hundred yards can change the court.

Courts that hear St. Louis-area injury suits

  • City of St. Louis: The 22nd Judicial Circuit, with civil matters at the Civil Courts Building downtown.
  • St. Louis County: The 21st Judicial Circuit, at the St. Louis County Courthouse in Clayton.
  • St. Charles County: The 11th Judicial Circuit, in the City of St. Charles.

These locations aren’t a promise of where every hearing happens. Your case notice and assigned division control that. You can look up case information through Missouri Courts.

Medical records matter too. Many serious crash injuries in this region are treated at Barnes-Jewish Hospital, Saint Louis University Hospital, or Mercy Hospital St. Louis. Records from the first visit help connect your injuries to the crash.

Crashes across the river

Plenty of St. Louis residents commute over the Poplar Street Bridge into the Metro East. An Illinois crash doesn’t automatically put your case in Illinois court or under Illinois law. A Missouri resident first injured outside Missouri may be able to sue in their home county (§ 508.010.5). Missouri courts pick the governing law using the most significant relationship test (Kennedy v. Dixon, 439 S.W.2d 173 (Mo. banc 1969)). And a claim already barred where it arose is barred in Missouri too (§ 516.190).

Who Gets Repaid From a Missouri UIM Settlement?

Subrogation is a payer’s legal right to be reimbursed from your recovery for bills it paid. Missouri does not let a personal injury claim be assigned, so privately insured health plans generally cannot enforce subrogation or reimbursement against a personal injury recovery (Waye v. Bankers Multiple Line Ins. Co., 796 S.W.2d 660 (Mo. App. W.D. 1990)). Certain government and federally governed payers are the main exceptions.

PayerCan it seek repayment from your recovery?Basis
MedicareYesFederal law
MO HealthNet (Medicaid)YesMo. Rev. Stat. § 208.215
Workers’ compensation insurerYesMo. Rev. Stat. § 287.150
Self-funded employer ERISA plan or federal-employee FEHBA planYesFederal law preempts the Missouri rule
Privately insured health planGenerally noWaye v. Bankers Multiple Line Ins. Co.

Repayment claims should be identified before any settlement is final. Otherwise the money you net can shrink after the fact. Our article on who pays car accident medical bills in Missouri explains how bills get covered while a claim is pending.

Before You Sign a Release, Talk to Chris Dixon

The moment the other driver’s insurer offers its limits is often when a UIM claim gets won or lost on paperwork. Your policy may set conditions on that settlement. Your 5-year window to sue the driver is running, and your insurer expects prompt notice.

The information on this page is for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Every case is unique, and past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Contact a qualified attorney to discuss your specific situation.

Chris Dixon and our team serve injured people across St. Louis, Clayton, Florissant, and St. Charles County. Bring your declarations pages and any letters from either insurer. Call 314-208-2808, any hour, to talk about your UIM claim. If we take your case, you pay nothing unless we recover for you.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does an underinsured motorist lawyer cost in St. Louis?

At The Dixon Injury Firm, car accident and UIM claims are handled on a contingency basis. You pay no attorney fee unless we recover money for you. The fee comes from the recovery as a percentage set in a written agreement. Case expenses are a separate item, so ask how they’re handled and review the agreement before signing.

How long do I have to file a UIM claim in Missouri?

In Missouri, a personal injury suit against the at-fault driver generally must be filed within 5 years under § 516.120, and a wrongful death suit within 3 years under § 537.100. Your policy cannot shorten the time to sue your own insurer, because § 431.030 voids those terms. Your policy’s prompt-notice and cooperation conditions still apply. When the clock starts on a UIM claim can depend on the facts, so confirm it early.

What is my UIM claim worth?

In Missouri, a UIM claim’s value depends on two separate questions. First, what are your full damages, including medical bills, future care, lost income, and pain and suffering? Second, what does your policy actually pay after its definition of “underinsured,” its limits, and any set-off are applied? No one can honestly name a number before reviewing both your records and your policy.

Should I accept the at-fault driver’s policy limits right away?

Not before checking your own policy. In Missouri, UIM is governed by your policy’s terms, and some policies set conditions on settling with or releasing the at-fault driver. Notify your own insurer about the offer in writing. Signing a release without reading those conditions could create problems with your UIM claim.

What if I was partially at fault for the crash?

Missouri follows pure comparative fault under Gustafson v. Benda, 661 S.W.2d 11 (Mo. banc 1983). Your recovery is reduced by your percentage of fault, but you can still recover even if you were more than 50% at fault. Your own insurer can raise fault arguments in a UIM claim, so evidence about how the crash happened still matters.

How long does a UIM claim take to settle?

There’s no reliable average for Missouri UIM claims. Timing depends on how long you’re treating, whether fault is disputed, how quickly the at-fault driver’s insurer pays its limits, and how your own insurer evaluates the gap. Claims involving ongoing treatment often wait for a clearer medical picture, balanced against the filing deadline. A lawsuit adds discovery time.

Do I need a lawyer for a UIM claim?

Missouri law doesn’t require one, and some smaller claims resolve without counsel. UIM claims involve policy definitions, possible set-offs, stacking questions, and settlement conditions that can be easy to miss. If your injuries are serious or your insurer disputes coverage, having a lawyer review the policy before you sign anything can help you understand your options.

What if the other driver had no insurance at all?

That’s an uninsured motorist claim, not a UIM claim. In Missouri, every personal auto liability policy must include UM coverage of at least $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident under § 379.203.1. It also covers hit-and-run drivers who left before being identified, whether or not the vehicles touched. Policy notice and reporting conditions still apply.

Will my UIM claim go to trial?

Most Missouri injury claims resolve without a trial, but some don’t. If your insurer’s offer doesn’t reflect the evidence and the policy, filing suit may be the stronger path. Filing also protects you when a deadline approaches while talks continue. Whether a case goes to trial depends on its facts and the parties’ positions.

How do I pay for medical treatment while my case is pending?

Most people in Missouri use their health insurance, Medicare, or MO HealthNet while the claim is open. Privately insured health plans generally cannot enforce reimbursement against a Missouri personal injury recovery. Medicare, MO HealthNet, workers’ compensation insurers, and certain federally governed plans can. Those repayment claims should be resolved before settlement is final.

Can I combine UIM coverage from more than one car?

That’s called stacking. Because UIM is optional in Missouri, your policy’s terms, including any anti-stacking or “other insurance” clause, generally decide whether limits can be combined. Gather declarations pages for every vehicle and every policy in your household so the full picture can be reviewed.

Does UIM coverage apply if a family member died in the crash?

It may, depending on the policy’s terms. In Missouri, the wrongful death claim against the at-fault driver must be filed within 3 years of the death under § 537.100. Under § 537.080, the spouse, children, descendants of deceased children, or parents have first priority to bring it. UIM coverage for a death claim depends on the policy’s definitions and limits.

Reviewed by Christopher R. DixonLast Updated: November 2026
Ryan B.
2 months ago
I highly recommend Chris Dixon to anyone dealing with a personal injury case. He was there every step of the way, he was prompt and easy to get a hold of at any time during this process. He is very educated and highly skilled in his field and helped me receive the best medical attention possible. If you’re looking for the best personal injury in St. Louis, look no further. Chris Dixon, in my eyes, is the best!