In most St. Louis injury claims, you shouldn’t give a recorded statement to the at-fault driver’s insurer before getting legal advice. Injury lawyer Chris Dixon points out that you generally have no duty to give one. Under Missouri’s comparative fault rule, an offhand remark can also reduce your recovery. Your own insurer is different, since your policy may require cooperation.
What to do now:
Chris was born and raised in St. Louis. He takes over the insurance calls so injured people can focus on getting better, and he has recovered more than $60 million for clients. You pay no fee unless we win.
Call 314-208-2808 to talk it through.
Key Takeaways
On This Page:
It matters more than anything else on this page. Under Missouri law, your duties to an insurance company mostly come from your contract with it. Because you usually have no contract with the at-fault driver’s insurer, you generally aren’t required to give that company a recorded statement. Your own insurer can be different, because your policy may require you to cooperate with claims you make under it.
A recorded statement is an interview, usually by phone, that an insurance adjuster records with your permission. The adjuster asks about the crash, your injuries and often your medical history. The recording goes into the claim file, where it can be quoted later.
An adjuster is the insurance company employee who investigates a claim and recommends what the company should pay. The adjuster’s employer is the company whose money is on the line.
This adjuster works for the company that insures the person who hit you. That company’s interest is in paying no more than the facts and the policy require. Plenty of adjusters are pleasant on the phone. But nothing about that call is designed to protect your claim.
You can decline the recording and still report the basic facts.
Your auto policy probably includes a cooperation clause. This term requires you to help the company investigate claims you make under your coverage, which can include answering questions or giving a statement.
Missouri law voids any contract term that shortens your time to sue your own insurer (Mo. Rev. Stat. § 431.030). However, a policy’s prompt-notice and cooperation conditions still apply.
When the driver who hit you had no insurance, your claim usually runs through your own uninsured motorist (UM) coverage. UM coverage is the part of your policy that pays for injuries caused by a driver with no liability insurance.
Mo. Rev. Stat. § 379.203.1 requires every Missouri auto liability policy to include UM coverage at least at the state minimums of $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident. It also covers hit-and-run drivers who were never identified, whether or not the vehicles touched. Your policy’s notice and reporting conditions still apply.
Here’s the twist. In a UM claim, your own insurer becomes the company deciding what your injuries are worth.
In one documented case, our client was hit by a driver who had no insurance. We had to fight his own UM carrier to obtain his $1,000,000 policy limits. Past results don’t predict the outcome of another case. But that file shows why a statement to your “own” company still deserves preparation.
Underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage is optional in Missouri, and the policy’s own definition decides when it pays (Rodriguez v. General Accident Ins. Co. of Am., 808 S.W.2d 379 (Mo. banc 1991)). Many policies compare the other driver’s limits to your UIM limits rather than to your losses. Under that wording, UIM pays nothing when the other driver’s limits equal or exceed yours.
Who’s asking for your statement, and what you owe them
| Who is asking | Your relationship to them | Must you give a recorded statement? | What to do first |
|---|---|---|---|
| At-fault driver’s liability insurer | No policy contract with you | Usually not required | Decline politely and refer the adjuster to your lawyer |
| Your own insurer, vehicle damage claim | Policy contract | Your policy may require cooperation | Keep the call focused on the vehicle and check your policy’s cooperation terms |
| Your own insurer, uninsured motorist claim | Policy contract, with UM coverage required by Mo. Rev. Stat. § 379.203.1 | Your policy may require a statement or other cooperation | Prepare with your lawyer and meet the policy’s notice and reporting conditions |
| Your own insurer, underinsured motorist claim | Policy contract, with UIM coverage optional in Missouri | Depends on your policy’s cooperation terms | Confirm how your policy defines an underinsured driver before you talk |
Once you hire us, you stop taking the adjuster’s calls. We notify the insurers involved that you have a lawyer and ask that contact go through our office, so no one records you without preparation. You pay no fee unless we win. Ask us up front how case expenses are handled, since those are separate from attorney fees.
Handling insurer contact is one stage of a larger plan. The plan locks in the deadline, proves fault, measures the whole loss, finds every source of payment, and prepares for trial if the case needs it. You can see how those stages fit together in our overview of the personal injury claim process.
Every client works directly with the attorney handling the case, not a case manager or call center. We’re available 24/7, which helps when an adjuster leaves a voicemail late on a Friday.
Some of our attorneys spent earlier parts of their careers defending insurance companies. As a result, the team understands how carriers size up a claim before they ever make an offer.
Got a voicemail from an adjuster? Call 314-208-2808 before you return it. We’ll talk through who’s asking and what, if anything, you owe them.
Recorded statement requests often arrive before anyone knows who was at fault or how badly you’re hurt, and that timing is the problem. At that stage you may still be sore, medicated or waiting on an MRI. The adjuster, meanwhile, interviews people for a living.
An early recording does several things for the insurer:
None of this means every adjuster is acting in bad faith. It means the call serves the insurer’s file, not yours. For a closer look at how carriers try to shrink claims, see our breakdown of insurance company tactics.
But the fault questions are where a statement can do the most damage.
A recorded statement can hurt your claim by giving the insurer your own words to argue that you were partly at fault or less injured than you are. In Missouri, both arguments turn directly into dollars.
Comparative fault is the rule that divides responsibility for a crash among everyone who caused it. Missouri follows pure comparative fault, which the Missouri Supreme Court adopted in Gustafson v. Benda, 661 S.W.2d 11 (Mo. banc 1983). Your share of fault reduces your damages by that percentage, but it doesn’t bar recovery, even if you’re found more than 50% at fault.
At trial, the jury finds the total damages and each party’s percentage of fault. The court then reduces the award by your percentage.
Here’s a simple hypothetical. Suppose a jury found $100,000 in damages and put 20% of the fault on you. The court would reduce the award to $80,000. Every percentage point an insurer can pin on you, using your own recorded words, comes straight off the top.
Mo. Rev. Stat. § 304.012 requires every driver on Missouri roads to exercise “the highest degree of care.” That standard measures the driver who hit you. Insurers may also invoke it against you.
Questions like “When did you first see the other car?” or “Were you checking your mirrors?” can become an argument that you weren’t keeping a careful lookout. Right-of-way questions are a separate issue, governed by Mo. Rev. Stat. § 304.351.
Take a hypothetical. A Florissant driver is rear-ended on I-270. Two days later, the other driver’s adjuster calls, and she says she’s “okay, just a little sore.” Three weeks later, an MRI shows a herniated disc.
The insurer can now play her own words back to argue the disc injury came from something else. Her medical records can still tell the real story. She’s just arguing against her own recording to get there.
Common phrases and how insurers can use them
| What you might say | How it can be used | A safer approach |
|---|---|---|
| “I’m fine” or “I’m okay” | Cited as proof you weren’t hurt | Say you’re still being evaluated by your doctor |
| “I didn’t see them until the last second” | Argued as a failure to keep a careful lookout under Mo. Rev. Stat. § 304.012 | Let scene evidence and witnesses establish the timing |
| “I was going about 40” (a guess) | Treated as an admitted speed | Don’t estimate speeds or distances you didn’t measure |
| “My back has bothered me before” | Used to blame a prior condition | Let your medical records address your history |
| “I’m so sorry” | Framed as an admission of fault | Stick to facts and don’t assign blame |
You can be polite, confirm basic facts and decline to be recorded, all in the same short call. Declining a recording isn’t the same as refusing to report the crash or ignoring the claim.
Is saying no rude, or will it make me look guilty?
No. You’re making a reasonable choice to get advice before a recorded interview. Saying so politely doesn’t admit anything about the crash.
What if they offer money on the first call?
Early offers often come before the full extent of an injury is known. Before you say yes, read why it pays to think twice before you accept the first offer. If you’re still in the first days after a crash, our checklist on what to do after a car accident in St. Louis covers the basics. Most recorded statement requests follow vehicle collisions, and our St. Louis car accident lawyer page explains those claims in more depth.
If you already gave a recorded statement, it can’t be undone, but it’s only one piece of evidence and doesn’t decide your claim on its own. Medical records, scene photos, witness accounts and expert opinions can explain or outweigh an early remark.
Take these steps:
Being honest with your own lawyer fixes more than staying quiet ever will.
For claims under your own Missouri policy, refusing a reasonable cooperation request can put your coverage at risk, depending on the policy’s wording and the circumstances. That’s why the answer for your own insurer is usually “prepare,” not “refuse.”
These points help:
The other driver’s insurer is in a different position. It has no policy contract with you and no cooperation clause to enforce.
Most Missouri personal injury suits must be filed within 5 years under RSMo § 516.120, and wrongful death claims within 3 years of the death under Mo. Rev. Stat. § 537.100. Exceptions and special rules can change a deadline. A patient’s own medical negligence claim has a shorter 2-year limit with a 10-year repose period (Mo. Rev. Stat. § 516.105).
A statute of limitations is the legal deadline for filing a lawsuit. If you miss it, the claim is generally lost no matter how strong it was.
Weeks of calls, emails and recorded interviews with an adjuster aren’t a lawsuit. Only a timely filing preserves your claim in court.
Under Mo. Rev. Stat. § 508.010.4, when you were first injured in Missouri, a tort suit must be filed in the county where you were first injured. That rule applies regardless of where the defendants live.
Your summons or case notice will show the assigned division. You can check filings through Missouri Courts.
Many St. Louis residents work or drive across the river, so the location of the crash matters. An Illinois crash doesn’t automatically mean Illinois court or Illinois law. A Missouri resident first injured outside Missouri may be able to sue in their home county (Mo. Rev. Stat. § 508.010.5). Missouri courts choose the governing law using a most-significant-relationship test. And a claim that’s already time-barred where it arose is barred in Missouri too (Mo. Rev. Stat. § 516.190).
Christopher R. Dixon founded The Dixon Injury Firm and serves as its managing attorney. When you hire us, you talk directly with the attorney handling your case, and that attorney handles communications with the insurers.
Chris has practiced since 2007 and is licensed in Missouri and Illinois. He gained courtroom experience working with the St. Louis City Circuit Attorney’s Office during law school and earned his J.D. from Oklahoma City University School of Law.
His results include a $12 million wrongful death recovery for the family of a young girl killed in a car accident. Every case is different, and past results don’t predict future outcomes.
His recognitions include Super Lawyers®, The Best Lawyers in America® 2027 — Personal Injury Litigation – Plaintiffs, Top 100 Trial Lawyers from The National Trial Lawyers, and Lifetime Membership in the Million Dollar Advocates Forum. Learn more on Chris Dixon’s attorney profile, or read what clients say in our client reviews.
The information on this page is for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Every case is unique, and past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Contact a qualified attorney to discuss your specific situation.
Talk to us before you talk to them. An adjuster’s call can feel urgent, but your legal deadline is what actually controls. In most Missouri injury cases, that deadline is 5 years, while evidence like video and witness memories can disappear long before then. If an insurer wants your recorded statement, we’re available 24/7 for injured people across St. Louis, Clayton, Florissant and St. Charles County. Call 314-208-2808. You pay nothing unless we recover for you.
Usually not. In Missouri, your duties to an insurer generally come from your own policy, and you have no policy contract with the at-fault driver’s company. You can decline the recording, give basic facts like your name and the crash location, and ask that further questions come in writing. Your own insurer is different, because your policy’s cooperation clause may require you to help with claims you make under it.
Sometimes, and it’s worth asking. A written statement lets you choose your words carefully and keep a copy, but it can be quoted just like a recording. It’s wise to have a lawyer prepare or review any written account before it goes to an insurer, especially one that describes your injuries or how the crash happened.
The Dixon Injury Firm works on a no-fee-unless-we-win basis, so you don’t pay attorney fees unless we recover money for you. Case expenses, such as records or expert costs, are a separate topic. Ask how they’re handled before you sign a fee agreement, and we’ll explain it in plain language.
Most Missouri personal injury lawsuits must be filed within 5 years under Mo. Rev. Stat. § 516.120. Wrongful death claims have 3 years from the death under § 537.100. A patient’s own medical negligence claim generally has 2 years, with a 10-year repose limit, under § 516.105. Exceptions and special rules can change these deadlines, and negotiating with an adjuster isn’t a substitute for filing on time.
You can still recover in Missouri. Under the pure comparative fault rule from Gustafson v. Benda (Mo. banc 1983), your damages are reduced by your percentage of fault, even if you’re more than 50% responsible. That’s exactly why insurers ask detailed questions in recorded statements. Each percentage point they assign to you lowers what they pay.
Not before you know what your claim is worth. Early offers often arrive before your treatment is finished or your long-term prognosis is clear, and a signed settlement and release usually ends your claim. Compare any offer to your full medical costs, lost income, future care and your likely share of fault. Our guide on whether to accept the first offer goes deeper.
A reliable number usually isn’t possible on the first call. In Missouri, value depends on proof of fault, your share of fault if any, past and future medical costs, lost earnings and earning capacity, lasting limits on daily life, and the insurance available. Our explainer on what a Missouri car accident case is worth walks through those factors.
It depends on how long your treatment lasts, how clear fault is, how much coverage is available, and whether a lawsuit is needed. A claim often can’t be valued well until your doctors understand the long-term picture. Disputed fault, multiple insurers or reimbursement claims can add time.
Your own uninsured motorist coverage may pay. Mo. Rev. Stat. § 379.203.1 requires every Missouri auto liability policy to include UM coverage at least at $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident. It also covers unidentified hit-and-run drivers whether or not the vehicles made contact. Your policy’s notice and reporting conditions still apply, and your own insurer may ask for a statement, so prepare before you give one.
Many injury claims resolve without a trial, but some only resolve after a lawsuit is filed, and a few are tried to a jury. Preparing a case as though it could be tried gives you real options when an offer doesn’t reflect the evidence. Whether to accept a settlement is always your decision.
Many people use health insurance, Medicare or MO HealthNet, or medical coverage in their own auto policy. Subrogation, where the law allows it, is a payer’s right to be repaid from your recovery for bills it covered. Missouri generally doesn’t let ordinary privately insured health plans enforce it against a personal injury recovery (Waye v. Bankers Multiple Line Ins. Co., 1990). Medicare, MO HealthNet, workers’ compensation insurers and certain federal or self-funded employer plans can seek repayment. See who pays medical bills after a car accident for more.
Not every claim needs a lawyer, but a friendly tone doesn’t change whose interests the adjuster represents. Some injuries, like disc damage or concussion symptoms, can become clearer days or weeks later, after an early statement has already described you as fine. A short conversation with a lawyer before any recorded statement can help you decide.
Many personal injury law factories get as many clients in the door as possible, hoping one will be the jackpot. Not us. At The Dixon Injury Firm, we’re highly selective about our cases because we devote considerable time and attention to each client.